CAIE A Level Biology 9700 · Selection and evolution

Selection and evolution: compare question

Compare7 marksChallenge

A researcher investigates variation in leaf width (mm) in a species of alpine plant, Lobelia gibberosa. Two populations were sampled: Population A from a lowland valley (altitude 500 m) and Population B from a high-altitude ridge (altitude 2000 m). The summary statistics for leaf width from 30 individuals per population are shown below.

PopulationMean leaf width (mm)Standard deviation (mm)Sample size (n)
A (lowland)12.41.830
B (highland)10.12.130

An independent-samples t-test comparing the means gave a t-value of 2.45, with a p-value of 0.018 (significant at the 5% level).

Compare the two populations with respect to their variation in leaf width. In your answer, refer to:

  • the type of variation (discontinuous or continuous) shown within each population;
  • the likely genetic and environmental influences on this variation;
  • what the t-test result indicates about the difference in mean leaf width between the populations.
0 words · 7 marks

No account needed for your first marks. Your answer is used only to mark it.

How this question is marked

7 marks, so the mark scheme is looking for about 7 separate creditworthy points. Making the same point twice in different words earns it once.

Compare means: Give similarities or differences between two things, and say which side each point belongs to. Write each point as a pair, for example: A is X, whereas B is Y. Two separate descriptions rarely earn the marks.

More Selection and evolution questions

All Selection and evolution questions

Written by Markquill to follow the Cambridge International syllabus. Markquill is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Cambridge International.